Aug 27, 2018 trumps tweets incorrectly suggest that the land distribution process in south africa is disorderly and unlawful. These arguments vary tremendously over time and place. Central to land reform is its effect on food security. Land redistribution in south africa, trumps tweet, and us. Opinion in south africa, land apartheid lives on the new. The history of spatial planning in south africa, and more specifically in the western cape, is an interesting one as the planning system that exists is fragmented and fraught with confusion. A 5050 framework that shares out land while also ending the ability to make historical claims on particular properties, may offer south africa a way forward that, while still.
Diagnostic report on land reform in south africa commissioned report for high level panel on the assessment of key legislation and the acceleration of fundamental change, an initiative of the parliament of south africa institute for poverty, land and agrarian studies. It also highlights the different legislations that gave birth to the land reform exercise. In 2008 kas partnered with the southern african development community. Beneficiary participation and impact on land use in the waterberg district author links open overlay panel avhafunani j. Pdf land use and livelihoods in south africas land. The purpose and scope of the proposed tenure reform in the former homelands of south africa. Less than one in 20 land reform beneficiaries have benefited from either comprehensive agricultural support programme casp grants or microagricultural finance institutions of south africa mafisa loans. Africa land reform news, research and analysis the. The nature, scope and purpose of spatial planning in south.
Land reform is a deeply political process and therefore many arguments for and against it have emerged. South africas zuma outlines land reform plans bbc news. Asking questions about how to address this challenge is an urgent task. Section 25 5 provides that the state must take reasonable legislative and other measures, within its available resources, to foster conditions which enable citizens to gain access to land on an equitable basis.
Pdf land reform in south africa ben cousins academia. A worker uses a tractor to spray a field of crops during cropeating armyworm invasion at a farm in settlers, south africa, february 8, 2017. Introduction what is going wrong in south africa s postapartheid land reform programme, and how can its failings be addressed. Land, law and traditional leadership in south africa africa. What is going wrong in south africas postapartheid land reform programme, and. This briefing note examines the ancs record on land reform, outlines the winners and losers under the current dispensation, and offers a series of policy provocations. Why land reform is a key issue in south african elections. The topic i was asked to address, as indicated by the title, is restricted to a discussion of land tenure, property regimes and traditional leadership in communal areas. Twenty five years ago this month south africa s leaders agreed an historic constitution that paved the way for the end of white rule. Perceptions regarding land reform debate, progress made and challenges encountered in. Land redistribution in south africa commissioned report for high level panel on the assessment of key legislation and the. Broader issues of land reform, including redistribution, are beyond.
Given the above examples, the chapter looks at the zimbabwean land reform programme, focusing on its goals, objectives, models, achievements and failures. But despite the end of apartheid, the majority of land. Dr john purchase, ceo of the agricultural business chamber, agbiz, examines current and planned developments in land reform. The bigger unresolved issue of land reform in the 21st century is the need to confront the overwhelming threat of ecological collapse. Jan 14, 2016 the impact that land reform had on the status of large carnivores in svc between 2000 and 2008 is then evaluated through an assessment of the population sizes of large carnivores in private, fasttrack resettlement hereafter referred to as resettlement and communal land use types luts. With parliamentary processes ready to resume in 2019, the issue of land expropriation in south africa enters its final constitutional hurdle. One of the new resolutions on land related to namibias urban areas, like the. Four scenarios for land reform in south africa contains four scenarios about what could happen in the context of land reform in south africa by 2030. Foreigners will be banned from owning land in south africa under new proposals outlined by president jacob zuma. Officials also note that 11 000 new smallholder farmers have. South africa currently has over 60% citizens whose land property rights are not recorded nor registered. It is not possible to isolate the values of corrupt activities from these recorded amounts, but it is clear that if the wasted expenditures from corruption are even a fraction of these amounts, there are significant costs to the south african economy. Land reform, implementation, land information system, cadastre, sustainable.
After the partition of the country into two parts north vietnam and south vietnam, the communist land reform 19531956 redistributed land to more than 2 million poor peasants, but at a cost of thousands, possibly tens of thousands of lives and contributed to the exodus of up to 1 million people from the north to the south in 1954 and 1955. Acknowledgement that land reform in south africa is necessary, even though a complex and emotive subject. South africans believe land reform is an intrinsic part of the postapartheid historical. Since 1995 he has focused on the south african land reform programme and democratisation in rural south africa. This paper is an analysis of papers, reports and legislation that deals with land reform in south africa. Land reform tops the list of priorities affecting south african agriculture, given the current policy environment in which the sector operates. Budgets for land reform have generally been around 1% of the national budget, and have fallen from a peak of 1. Land reform has to, must take place in south africa. Government will at all times act in the best interest of our nation. The failure of land reform is attributed to an inappropriate logic of land reform 2, which we link to differences in how land is understood, giving rise to application of inappropriate theory for the context 3, 4.
The current status and future of land reform in south africa. The land audit is complete and we now have a picture of the patterns of ownership. These policy interventions, which have included support for land reform, the provision of social grants, field crop. Land redistribution in south africa parliament of south. Land reform will continue to be one of south africa s biggest problems south africa s youngsters are let down by a lousy education system south africa needs a broader choice of leadership options. South african history 1652 1902 culminating in the anglo. It indicates that from 2009 to december 2011, about 823 300 hectares of land were acquired and allocated to 20 290 beneficiaries, an improvement over previous years that indicates that our systems are improving. Pdf in the paper land reform in south african political discourse will be. Land audit report your worldwide south african community. Land reform in south africa is sinking nelson mandela foundation. Much of this land was previously cattle ranches, with limited. This has resulted in issues, confusion and conflicts which has resulted in numerous court cases.
In 2015, president jacob zuma said he was seeking a ban on foreign land ownership, as well as limiting the total area of land holdings to 12,000 hectares per individual of any nationality. Land reform in south africa getting back on track may 2008 cde executive summary this is an executive summary of cde research no 16, land reform in south africa. In this section, we zero in on masvingo province in the central south and east of the country. In each of these countries the process of land reform is incomplete.
The paper argues that the logic of land reform as a whole needs to be rethought, rather than merely tinkering with details. The reality could not be further from what we had suspected all along. Land expropriation without compensation the loaded. Land reform has embarked on a series of legisla tive and policy reforms to give meaning to our land reform and rural development programme as espoused in the national governments key priorities.
It is believed to allow previously unemployed people to participate in the economy and better the countrys economic growth. Mar 29, 2016 land reform tops the list of priorities affecting south african agriculture, given the current policy environment in which the sector operates. Progress to date1 edward lahiff2 introduction and background this paper provides an overview of land reform in south africa since the advent of democratic government in 1994, with a particular emphasis on land redistribution. According to statistics south africa, in 2014 whites made up 8. The need for land reform south africa suffered a long history of colonization, racial domination and land dispossession that. As a result the land reform process in south africa has largely adopted the ideology and guidelines outlined earlier. Problem description since the dawn of democracy in south africa no official information has been published on land ownership according race, gender and nationality. First, environmental advocates argue that particular aspects of precolonial african land systems should be retained for their inherent resource. Twenty two years after the transition to democracy and the commencement of land reform, there is a great deal of lived experience to. Human rights, civil society and the contradictions of land. Land reform is necessary in south africa, but that is about the only issue regarding land reform on which there is consensus.
This paper examines the land reform programme in south africa, assesses how government policy has affected human rights with respect to access to land, and explores the roles of civil society in. The native land act of 19 played a key role in the restriction of native people of south africa sa to occupy only % of the countrys land feinberg, 1993, louw, 20. In this regard, the south african government has since 1994 been involved in designing and developing a land reform programme that aims to bring about a fair and equitable land dispensation in south africa in an orderly and planned way. Despite this, africa suffers from the highest poverty rate in the world with nearly 47. Although the south african government has made significant investments in land reform, the ruling african. This restriction resulted in huge differences in land holdings between people of european descent, who occupied on average 1600 ha per person and native people, who occupied only 1. An examination of absolute poverty between 2006 and 2015. Land grabbing over nearly 350 years of south african history saw the loss of key. Land reform in south africa needs to be addressed, but it shouldnt come at the cost of food security or by breaking up economically efficient enterprises. Jan 16, 2015 in south africa, land apartheid lives on. Land use and livelihoods in south africa s land reform. Land reform and rural development require a bold new approach to ensure that justice is done, that land reform beneficiaries are made permanently better off, and that south african agriculture transforms and continues to attract investment, generates export earnings and provides a growing number of good jobs. The impact of land reform on the status of large carnivores. Diagnostic report on land reform in south africa commissioned report for high level panel on the assessment of key legislation and the acceleration of fundamental change, an initiative of the parliament of south africa institute for poverty, land and agrarian studies university of the western cape september 2016.
When we start unpacking why land reform is necessary, some people say it is because the majority of south africans were disenfranchised and disempowered through years of colonial conquest, segregation and apartheid. Land reform in south africa is an emotive, complex, and important issue, and it. Officials also note that 11 000 new smallholder farmers have been established since 2009, out of a target of 50 000. These are not predictions of what will happen or recommendations about what should happen. What do south africans think about land reform in terms of its social and public benefit. South africas land reform in historical perspective. An overview of precolonial land systems the nature of indigenous south african land systems is significant to plans for postapartheid land reform in three respects.
We hope it will stimulate interest in the fulllength report, in which the issues and recommendations briefly described here are discussed in depth. Land redistribution in south africa commissioned report for high level panel on the assessment of key legislation and the acceleration of fundamental change, an initiative of the parliament of south africa thembela kepe university of toronto rhodes university and. Land reform in south africa konradadenauerstiftung. The people have voiced their impatience and the inequalities are threatening peace and stability in our country. Theories of land reform and their impact on land reform. Pdf south africas land reform in historical perspective. Although the south african government has made significant investments in land reform, the ruling african national congress has made decisions and. Zimbabwe, on one side of the spectrum, is facing a crisis in democratisation due to its radical approach to land reform. The first part tries to understand the case for redistributive land reforms. Mendola and simtowe, 2015 emphasize the fact that the purpose of land reform is to.
Apr 07, 2015 the experiences of zimbabwe and namibia provide examples that the south african authorities can draw upon as they formulate their new land reform policies. The first phase of the land reform is covered by the period 1980 to 1998. The public hearings were hosted in september and october 2014, with the final report published in august 2015. African customary law is upheld by the south african constitution section 2. A critical analysis of the land reform programme in zimbabwe. Centre for landrelated, regional and development law and policy clrdp at the. South africa yearbook 201516 government communication and. The 2012 world bank report on agricultural land redistribution emphasizes the link between economic.
Land remains an emotive fault line in south africa. Final report by the presidential advisory panel on land reform. The three key elements of south africas comprehensive land reform. South africas land reform challenges market news, news. There is need to show who owns south african land and to track progress of land reform to fulfil section 255 of the. Land reform is probably one of the most difficult domestic policy issues to be dealt with by zimbabwe, namibia, south africa and australia. Communal land, property rights and traditional leadership.
Foreword by the deputy minister5 foreword by the director. Banerjee massachusetts institute of technology abstract the paper is in two parts. Land reform in south africa is a moral, social and economic imperative. Opinion in south africa, land apartheid lives on the. Here, land reform is understood to include the related concepts of land redistribution. According to a 2017 land audit by the south african government, 72 percent of the countrys arable land remains in the hands of whites, who account for fewer than 10 percent of the total. President donald trump touched off a diplomatic row with south africa by repeating an erroneous broadcast about land reform there. Despite over two decades of intervention, land reform in south africa is failing 1. Diagnostic report on land reform in south africa parliament of. South africans believe land reform is an intrinsic part of the post apartheid historical. The governments land reform programme is made up of the following principal components. Land reform has been a crucial topic since the end of apartheid. Addressing shortcomings of land tenure reform in customary.
A pilot land reform programme was designed lund, 1996 following more or less the guidelines of the marketassisted. He is currently working on agrarian movements in south africa, and on land and poverty. Land reform will continue to be one of south africas. So says the south african property owners association sapoa, whose members comprise 90 percent of the commercial property sector in south africa neil gopal sapoa chief executive officer says south africa needs a robust and balanced debate around land reform. It is a precondition for the success of governments growth, employment and redistribution strategy. Current estimates indicate that around 80 per cent of south african agricultural land remains in the hands of approximately 35,000 white farmers and large agribusinesses.
The main reason land reform in south africa has been lethargic is not the constitution, but a flawed approach. Pdf the historical context of land reform in south africa and. It begins with a brief sketch of the historical background before outlining the main. Land reform in south africa is the promise of land restitution to empower farm workers who now have the opportunity to become farmers and reduce inequality. The land debate looks at what government has done to address land reform in south africa since the country became a democracy in 1994. Land available for use by africans was increased by 5% in 1936 fn5 bringing the total to % of the total area of south africa, although much of the land remained in the ownership of the state through the south african development trust supposedly held in trust for the african people. Land policy proposals south african history online. A new expropriation bill was introduced in 2015 and approved by parliament in 2016. News24 2015 despite much rhetoric on the subject by government and public officials in the immediate postapartheid. South africa yearbook 2015 16 this publication is the official authoritative reference work on the republic of south africa and is updated annually.
1442 4 577 244 1181 537 999 737 1314 597 1483 369 1472 891 1348 1465 905 1084 1089 24 1271 695 255 93 803 883 1296 9 414 1166 536 1275 1311